Here’s the thing about Pinterest analytics—most people are measuring the wrong stuff. They’re celebrating repins and followers while their actual business sits there, wondering where all the customers went.
I get it. Pinterest feels like this mysterious black box where you throw content in and hope something magical happens. But here’s what I’ve learned after driving thousands of visitors (and actual paying customers) from Pinterest: tracking the right metrics is everything.
Let’s ditch the vanity metrics and focus on what actually moves the needle in your business and provides traffic to your website.
Table of Contents
Why Most Pinterest Analytics Miss the Mark
Most Pinterest marketing guides tell you to track impressions, saves, and clicks. Sure, those numbers feel good, but they don’t pay your bills. The real question isn’t “How many people saw my pin?”—it’s “How many people became customers because of Pinterest?”
This is where most Pinterest strategies fall apart. They focus on Pinterest-only metrics instead of connecting Pinterest performance to actual business results. That’s like celebrating how many people walked into your store without tracking how many actually bought something. Here’s the thing about Pinterest analytics—most people are measuring the wrong stuff. They’re celebrating repins and followers while their actual business sits there, wondering where all the customers went.
I get it. Pinterest feels like this mysterious black box where you throw content in and hope something magical happens. But here’s what I’ve learned after driving thousands of visitors (and actual paying customers) from Pinterest: tracking the right metrics is everything.
Let’s ditch the vanity metrics and focus on what actually moves the needle in your business and provides traffic to your website.
Why Most Pinterest Analytics Miss the Mark
Most Pinterest marketing guides tell you to track impressions, saves, and clicks. Sure, those numbers feel good, but they don’t pay your bills. The real question isn’t “How many people saw my pin?”—it’s “How many people became customers because of Pinterest?”
This is where most Pinterest strategies fall apart. They focus on Pinterest-only metrics instead of connecting Pinterest performance to actual business results. That’s like celebrating how many people walked into your store without tracking how many actually bought something.
The Pinterest Metrics That Actually Matter for Your Business
Here’s the metrics to track when it comes to your Pinterest account…
1. Conversion-Focused Traffic Metrics
Instead of just tracking Pinterest clicks, dive deeper into your Google Analytics or website analytics. Set up UTM parameters for your Pinterest links so you can see exactly which pins are sending qualified traffic that converts.
Look for metrics like:
- Time spent on your website from Pinterest traffic
- Pages per session from Pinterest visitors
- Email signups from Pinterest traffic
- Actual sales attributed to Pinterest
2. Long-Term Pinterest SEO Performance
Pinterest is a search engine, which means your pins can keep driving traffic months after you publish them. Track which of your pins are still getting clicks 6-12 months later—these are your Pinterest SEO goldmines.
Use Pinterest’s native analytics to identify:
- Top performing pins by total clicks (not just recent activity)
- Seasonal trends in your Pinterest traffic
- Which keywords are driving the most qualified traffic
3. Email List Growth from Pinterest
Your email list is where your VIPs hang out—treat it like one. Pinterest should be feeding your email funnel consistently. Track how many newsletter subscribers you’re getting from Pinterest traffic versus other sources.
Set up dedicated landing pages for Pinterest traffic and monitor:
- Conversion rates on Pinterest-specific lead magnets
- Quality of Pinterest subscribers (do they open emails and buy?)
- Pinterest-to-customer conversion rates
Setting Up Pinterest Analytics for Real Business Results
Connect Pinterest Analytics to Your Business Goals
Pinterest’s built-in analytics tell part of the story, but connecting Pinterest to your broader marketing funnel tells the complete picture. Use Google Analytics 4 or your preferred analytics platform to track the customer journey from Pinterest pin to purchase.
Here’s my simple tracking setup:
- UTM parameters on all Pinterest links
- Pinterest-specific landing pages for key content
- Conversion tracking for email signups and sales
- Monthly reporting on Pinterest ROI
Track Pinterest Automation Performance
If you’re using Pinterest automation tools (and you should be), track how automated pins perform versus manual pins. Pinterest automation can be a game-changer for consistent traffic, but you need to monitor the results.
Key Pinterest automation metrics to watch:
- Engagement rates on automated vs. manual pins
- Traffic quality from automated Pinterest marketing strategies
- Time saved through automation vs. results maintained
Pinterest Keywords That Convert (Not Just Get Clicks)
Here’s where most Pinterest strategy advice gets it wrong—they focus on high-volume keywords instead of high-converting keywords. The best Pinterest keywords for your business are the ones that attract people ready to take action.
Finding Conversion-Focused Pinterest Keywords
Use Pinterest’s search bar to discover what your ideal customers are actually searching for. Look for specific, problem-solving keywords rather than broad terms.
Instead of targeting “blogging advice,” try:
- “how to start a profitable blog”
- “blog traffic strategies that work”
- “pinterest marketing guide for bloggers”
These longer-tail keywords attract people who are past the browsing stage and ready to solve a problem.
Pinterest Keyword Strategy for Different Business Goals
Match your Pinterest keywords to where people are in your customer journey:
For brand awareness: Broader Pinterest SEO terms like “blogging 101” or “learn pinterest”
For lead generation: Action-oriented keywords like “pinterest apps” or “pinterest hacks”
For sales: Buying-intent keywords like “best pinterest tools” or “pinterest automation”
Tracking Pinterest Business Account Performance
Your Pinterest business account gives you access to Pinterest analytics, but most people don’t dig deep enough into the data. Here’s what to focus on:
Pinterest Growth Metrics That Matter
- Audience quality over quantity: Are your new followers actually your ideal customers?
- Pin performance longevity: Which pins keep performing months later?
- Referral traffic trends: Is Pinterest sending consistent traffic or sporadic bursts?
Using Pinterest Analytics to Improve Your Strategy
Pinterest analytics show you what’s working, but they also reveal opportunities you’re missing. Look for patterns in your top-performing pins:
- What keywords do they target?
- What visual styles perform best?
- Which pin descriptions drive the most clicks?
- What time of day/week do your pins get the most engagement?
Pinterest Apps and Tools for Better Tracking
The right Pinterest tools can automate your tracking and give you insights that Pinterest’s native analytics miss. Look for tools that connect Pinterest performance to your broader business metrics.
Essential Pinterest marketing tools for tracking:
- Pinterest analytics extensions that show historical data
- UTM parameter generators for consistent link tracking
- Pinterest automation platforms with built-in analytics
- Social media management tools with Pinterest reporting features
Turning Pinterest Traffic Into Paying Customers
Traffic without conversion is just expensive entertainment. Here’s how to ensure your Pinterest traffic actually grows your business:
Create Pinterest-Specific Landing Pages
Don’t send outbound clicks from Pinterest traffic to your homepage and hope for the best. Create dedicated landing pages that speak directly to what your Pinterest audience is looking for.
These pages should:
- Match the promise of your Pinterest pin
- Include clear calls-to-action
- Capture email addresses before visitors leave
- Guide people to your best content or products
Pinterest Marketing Strategies That Convert
The most effective Pinterest marketing strategies focus on the entire customer journey, not just getting pin clicks. Plan your Pinterest content around:
- Top of funnel: Educational pins that attract your ideal audience
- Middle of funnel: Problem-solving content that builds trust
- Bottom of funnel: Product-focused pins that drive sales
The Real Pinterest ROI Formula
Here’s the Pinterest tracking formula that actually matters:
(Revenue from Pinterest customers) – (Time + Tools invested in Pinterest) = Your real Pinterest ROI
This means tracking beyond Pinterest analytics into your actual business results. How much revenue can you directly attribute to Pinterest? How much time are you investing in getting those results?
What to Do When Pinterest Traffic Isn’t Converting
If you’re getting Pinterest traffic but not conversions, the problem usually isn’t with Pinterest—it’s with your conversion process. Check:
- Landing page alignment: Does your page deliver on what your pin promised?
- Load speed: Pinterest users expect fast-loading pages
- Mobile optimization: Most Pinterest traffic comes from mobile devices
- Clear next steps: What exactly do you want Pinterest visitors to do?
Ready to Turn Pinterest Into Your Traffic Machine That Actually Pays?
Pinterest can be an incredible source of qualified traffic and paying customers, but only if you’re tracking the right metrics and optimizing for conversion, not just engagement.
The key is connecting Pinterest performance to your real business goals and measuring what matters most to your bottom line.
Looking to automate your Pinterest marketing and track results that actually matter?
BlogToPin makes it easy to maintain a consistent Pinterest presence while focusing on the metrics that grow your business. Let Pinterest work for you while you focus on what you do best—creating amazing content and serving your audience.
Save this strategy for later—then tell me which Pinterest metric you’ll start tracking first!
Here’s the thing about Pinterest analytics—most people are measuring the wrong stuff. They’re celebrating repins and followers while their actual business sits there, wondering where all the customers went.
I get it. Pinterest feels like this mysterious black box where you throw content in and hope something magical happens. But here’s what I’ve learned after driving thousands of visitors (and actual paying customers) from Pinterest: tracking the right metrics is everything.
Let’s ditch the vanity metrics and focus on what actually moves the needle in your business and provides traffic to your website.
Pin for later …
0 Comments