“Just hit 10K followers on Pinterest!”
Sounds impressive, right? But what if I told you I’ve seen accounts with 500 followers driving more traffic, generating more sales, and creating more impact than accounts with 100,000+ followers?
The dirty little secret of Pinterest success is that the follower count is about as useful as a chocolate teapot. While the rest of the social media world obsesses over follower milestones, savvy Pinterest marketers are quietly focusing on metrics that actually move the needle.
Let me show you why this platform breaks all the traditional social media rules and what you should be focusing on instead.
Understanding Pinterest’s Unique Algorithm
Unlike Instagram or Facebook, Pinterest functions more like a search engine than a social network. Think of it as Google with pretty pictures. When users come to Pinterest, they’re not necessarily looking to keep up with their favourite creators – they’re searching for solutions, inspiration, and ideas. This fundamental difference means that your content’s success depends far more on its searchability and quality than on how many followers you have.
The Smart Feed, Pinterest’s content distribution system, prioritises relevance over recency or creator popularity. This means that a pin from an account with 100 followers can easily outperform one with 100,000 followers if it better serves the user’s needs.
Why Pinterest Follower Count Is Just a Vanity Metric
Let’s get real: having a large follower count might look impressive, but it doesn’t necessarily translate to meaningful engagement or, more importantly, website traffic. Here’s why:
- Pinterest’s search-based discovery means your content can reach millions without a single follower
- Viral pins often come from smaller accounts with highly relevant, quality content
- Pins have a significantly longer lifespan than posts on other platforms – we’re talking months or even years of engagement
What Really Drives Pinterest Success
Instead of focusing on a high follower account, here’s what you should do to boost Pinterest account.
1. Search Engine Optimisation (SEO)
SEO is your golden ticket to Pinterest success. To maximise your reach, leverage these powerful tools:
- Blogtopin: Perfect for converting blog content into Pinterest-optimised descriptions
- Pinclicks: Helps analyse and optimise your pin titles and descriptions for maximum searchability
- Tailwind’s Keyword Tool: Identifies trending keywords in your niche and suggests optimal placement
Pro Tip: Focus on long-tail keywords that specifically target your audience’s search intent. Don’t just optimise for “healthy recipes” – go for “quick healthy breakfast recipes for busy moms” instead.
2. Quality Visual Content
Your pins need to stop the scroll and demand attention. While creativity is key, you don’t need to start from scratch. Here are some premium resources for stunning visuals:
- Hautestock: Offers sophisticated, on-trend stock photos perfect for Pinterest
- Vault Socials: Provides premium stock videos and images that can help your pins stand out
When creating pins:
- Use vertical images (2:3 ratio is optimal)
- Include clear, readable text
- Maintain brand consistency
- Create multiple pin designs for the same content
Don’t have the time? Try our Pinterest templates to help you create jaw-dropping pins in minutes.
3. Strategic Pinning
Success on Pinterest requires a systematic approach:
- Pin consistently (10-25 pins daily)
- Create fresh content regularly
- Organise boards strategically
- Pin during peak times (typically evenings and weekends)
4. Meaningful Metrics to Track
Instead of obsessing over follower count, focus on these metrics:
- Monthly unique viewers
- Pin impressions
- Click-through rates (aim for 2-5%)
- Save rates
- Website traffic from Pinterest
Action Steps for Growth
- IMPLEMENT KEYWORD RESEARCH
- Set up a Tailwind account for keyword research
- Use Blogtopin to optimise existing content
- Track performance with Pinclicks
- CREATE A CONTENT CALENDAR
- Plan your pin creation schedule
- Vary content types (static pins and video pins)
- Schedule regular content audits
- DEVELOP A PIN DESIGN STRATEGY
- Subscribe to Hautestock or Vault Socials for premium visuals
- Create templates for consistent branding
- Test different designs and track performance
- SETUP ANALYTICS
- Enable Pinterest Analytics
- Connect Google Analytics
- Track monthly progress across key metrics
Conclusion
Stop counting followers and start counting what really matters – engagement, clicks, and conversions. Pinterest success isn’t about building a massive following; it’s about creating valuable, discoverable content that serves your target audience’s needs.
Focus on optimising your pins for search, creating stunning visuals, and maintaining a consistent pinning strategy. Use the tools mentioned to streamline your workflow and improve your content’s performance. Remember, a small account with well-optimised, high-quality content will almost always outperform a large account with mediocre content.
Ready to transform your Pinterest strategy? Start by implementing one of these focus areas today. Your future self (and your analytics) will thank you.
This is all such great information! I didn’t realize different social media can be so different when you post/pin/etc. Thanks for sharing!
All of these are fantastic tools to make money, Candice! I use many of them, but have always wanted to try BlogtoPin, I’m so intrigued by it, I always create my own pins in Canva but that would be so helpful if it did it for me!
Make Life Marvelous
That’s so true, BlogtoPin is a huge time-saver! It really speeds up the Pinterest process so you can focus on content creation.
Love all of these blog traffic tips for the holidays, Candice! It’s so hard to believe it’s almost holiday time and it’s always great to get ahead as much as possible with content.
Wishing you a wonderful rest of your week! 🙂
Make Life Marvelous